How to solve external hard drive read-only without formatting on Mac?

By Katrina | Posted to Home > NTFS for Mac Tips, updated on September 9th, 2021

Summary: You will find the efficient methods to solve Mac external hard drive read-only error. Free download iBoysoft NTFS for Mac if external hard drive is NTFS file system.

Fix external hard drive read-only on Mac

Usually, you can read and write to files on an external hard drive on your Mac, but there are chances that this external hard drive shows read-only on Mac. For example, many people have reported that their WD My Passport read-only on Mac and don't know how to unlock Seagate external hard drive read-only on Mac.

This post will analyze the three external hard drive read-only cases. Then, you can find a relevant and feasible solution to fix Mac external hard drive read-only issue without formatting.

Here are the main causes of why your external hard drive is read-only on Mac:

Case 1: The file system of external hard drive is NTFS

A file system controls how data is stored and retrieved on a disk. There are many different kinds of file systems, and each one has different structure and logic, properties of speed, flexibility, security, size, etc.

By default, Windows uses Microsoft NTFS file system while Mac uses HFS+ and APFS for OS volume. FAT32 and exFAT are usable for both Windows and Mac operating systems. That's to say, you are unable to write to NTFS drive on Mac.

If you try to copy or drag files to an NTFS-formatted external hard drive on Mac, you'll be unable to but see the greyed-out no symbol as below.

Can't copy or drag files to NTFS drives on Mac

And when you open files on this external hard drive, you will find your documents being read-only.

Therefore, if you find your external hard drive read-only, the first thing that comes to your mind should be to check if this drive is NTFS file system.

How do I know if my external hard drive is NTFS file system?

Simply, you can check this by viewing its disk information either in Disk Utility or in the Finder, and here is how.

Method 1: Check it in Disk Utility

  • 1. Click on Launchpad at the dock of your Mac and choose Other in the menu.
  • 2. Choose Disk Utility among these utilities and open it.
  • 3. When it is launched, click on the external hard drive you have read-only problem with in the left sidebar. You will see an obvious "Windows NT File System" in the right column.
  • Windows NT File System in Disk Utility

Method 2: Check it in the Finder

You can also check this in the Finder with a few clicks.

  • 1. Open the Finder and right-click on this external hard drive.
  • 2. Choose Get info in the context menu.
  • 3. You will see "Windows NT File System (NTFS)" after File system if the read-only drive is formatted with Microsoft NTFS file system.
  • external hard drive is not writable on Mac

How to fix NTFS external hard drive read-only issue on Mac:

Then, after making sure that it is the Windows NTFS file system that makes your external hard drive read-only on Mac, you can go head to fix this problem. Try to repair the read-only external hard drive with or without formatting.

Solution 1: Using NTFS for Mac tool

If you have important files on this external hard drive, and you frequently swap your work between Windows and Mac, formatting this drive definitely is the last solution you would resort to. The reason is, as you may know, formatting will wipe your data out of this drive and cause data loss.

Then when external drive is NTFS-formatted, how can you fix the read-only drive without formatting?

An NTFS driver for Mac should be the most convenient tool for you to fix this read-only issue without formatting. With an NTFS for Mac software, you can use NTFS external hard drives natively and seamlessly on your Mac.

Here, iBoysoft NTFS for Mac is your best choice. This easy-to-operate NTFS for Mac software can make the NTFS drives readable and writable on Mac.

About iBoysoft NTFS for Mac

iBoysoft NTFS for Mac can mount NTFS external hard drives in read-write mode on your Mac, granting people full access to read NTFS drive on Mac and write files on NTFS-formatted drives.

iBoysoft NTFS for Mac- Best NTFS Disk Management for Mac

  • Grant full access to Windows NTFS file system on Mac
  • Read, write, modify, transfer, and delete files on NTFS drives on Mac
  • Erase disks to NTFS file system on Mac
  • Unmount multiple drives with one click
  • Support macOS 11 to macOS 10.13
  • Fully support Apple M1 Mac

iBoysoft NTFS for Mac is also a wonderful tool to manage NTFS external drives on Mac. It's a menu bar app, from which users can mount, repair, erase NTFS hard drives, external hard drives, SD cards, USB flash drives, etc. with a simple click.

Tutorial to write to NTFS-formatted external hard drive on Mac with iBoysoft NTFS for Mac

  • 1. Free download and install iBoysoft NTFS for Mac on your computer, and then restart the Mac.
  • 2. Connect NTFS external hard drive to Mac and launch iBoysoft NTFS for Mac.
  • 3. Write to NTFS external hard drive after the external hard drive is mounted successfully.
  • Write to NTFS external hard drive on Mac with iBoysoft NTFS for Mac

Solution 2: Enable NTFS read-write with Terminal (not recommend)

You can also try the experimental method to enable NTFS read-write support with command prompt on your Mac. However, it is not recommended as it is not stable and could result in data loss if it goes wrong. So, use the command line with caution!

Warning: Do not use this method as a long-term solution to write to NTFS drives that contain important files. Meanwhile, do not use this method if you are not familiar with the command line, in case that you input a wrong command and cause unexpected damage to your Mac and drives.

Well, if you insist…here is how to do this:

  • 1. Click Go at the upper right of your desktop and go to the Applications > Utilities > Terminal.
  • 2. Input "sudo nano /etc/fstab" to edit the fstab file (supply your password when prompted).
  • 3. Type "LABEL=NAME none ntfs rw,auto,nobrowse" in the editor window for the fstab file. (Be sure to change the word NAME to the name of your drive)
  • 4. Press Control + O to save the file, followed byControl + X to exit.
  • 5. Unmount your NTFS drive and attach it again.

Solution 3: Reformat external hard drive to exFAT/FAT32

It is possible that you just recently bought a new hard drive and found it is formatted as NTFS. In this case, if you don't have anything important on this drive or you have a copy of a data backup, you can simply format this external hard drive without worrying about data loss.

To formatting this read-only hard drive, you can just go to Disk Utility and Erase it. There are several formats you can choose, and erasing this disk into which file system depends on how you intend to use the drive.

  • APFS: If you plan to use the drive on macOS 11 Big Sur, 10.15 Catalina, macOS 10.14 Mojave, and macOS 10.13 High Sierra, you can format it into APFS for better experience.
  • HFS+: It is also known as Mac OS Extended, whose later versions added journaling to prevent corruption of the file system structure. Therefore, you can choose HFS+ if you are going to use this external hard drive on macOS Sierra and earlier Mac operating systems.
  • FAT32/exFAT: If your storage device is an SD card or USB flash drive, and you'd like to read-write this portable drive both on Mac and Windows OS, you'd better erase it with exFAT or FAT32.

Case 2: Disk permissions are changed as read-only

The Sharing and Permissions option is set up to determine who can delete or modify a file or program copied to the drive. Thus, if the permissions are changed by you or others, a message will pop up and inform you that the file is read-only or you don't have permission to save when you save changes to this disk.

In this case, if you right-click on the icon of your disk and choose "Get info" to check the disk information, you will find you can only read this external hard drive or SD card even though it is not NTFS file system. That's to say, you can't write to this drive.

If this is the cause for your external hard drive being read-only, you can try the following solutions and fix this issue without formatting your drive.

The Sharing & Permissions shows disk as you can only read

Solution 1: Change the permission of this external hard drive

If your files on this external hard drive show as read-only or locked, or if you try to move some files to the Trash but get no response, you can try to change the permission of this disk.

  • 1. Open the Finder and find your external hard drive in the left sidebar.
  • 2. Right-click on this drive or volume and choose Get info, and then scroll down to Sharing & Permissions.
  • 3. Extend this column by clicking on the triangle symbol, and then click on the Lock icon.
  • 4. Input the password of your Mac, and click on Read only, then change your privilege as Read & Write in the right column.
  • 5. Click the gear button (Action menu) at the bottom of the window, choose Apply to enclosed items, and then click OK to confirm the action.

Solution 2: Ignore Permissions on external hard drive in the Finder

To prevent such errors from happening, Mac operating system includes a setting to ignore Permissions on external drives, so all files on the drive should be fully accessible regardless of their Permissions settings. Here below are steps to ignore the permission on external hard drives:

Step 1: Select the external hard drive on your desktop or in the Finder sidebar, and then press Command + I to get information on the drive.

Step 2: Click on the arrow that is on the left side of the Sharing & Permissions tab near the bottom of the window.

Step 3: Check the box to Ignore ownership on this volume, or toggle it off and then on if it's already enabled. (Provide the password of your Mac if it is required.)

Case 3: External hard drive corruption

Some internal errors will cause an external hard drive to be read-only as well. When this happens, your drive will be only mounted in read-only mode to prevent the data on it from corruption.

Solution: Repair external hard drive with Disk Utility

Fortunately, you can take some actions to repair these minor disk errors with Disk Utility on your Mac. You can use the following guide to fix read-only external hard drive in Disk Utility without formatting.

  • Step 1: Click Go at the upper right of your desktop and go to Utilities, and then open Disk Utility.
  • Step 2: Select the read-only external hard drive on the left window.
  • Step 3: Click First Aid in the and choose Run.

However, if First Aid can't repair your read-only external hard drive, the drive may be seriously corrupted due to some reasons. For instance, your disk becomes read-only after a macOS update.

Under this circumstance, if the solutions above are unable to fix this read-only external hard drive, you may need to format this drive. But formatting the corrupted drive will make data loss. You should rescue files off the external drive with data recovery software.

iBoysoft Mac Data Recovery, the free data recovery software, works to recover data from corrupted, unmounted, inaccessible hard drives with only a few clicks: Scan, Preview, and Recover. It is compatible with macOS Big Sur, Catalina, Mojave, and earlier OS versions.

Conclusion

Generally speaking, Mac external hard drive read-only issue appears when it is formatted with NTFS file system, corrupted, or set with read-only disk permission. The solutions above are useful to fix external hard drive read-only on Mac without formatting, while using NTFS for Mac software is most recommended.

Nevertheless, if your external hard drive is not NTFS formatted, and failed to repair with Disk Utility, it could be a failed external hard drive which needs to be replaced, or you can try your luck by sending it to a local disk repair service.