Home > Questions

APFS and Mac OS Journaled, which one is better?

Hi guys! Recently I want to format my external hard drive so I can use it for my new MacBook Air 2021. My friends told me before that both APFS and Mac OS Extended (Journaled) are good file systems. Which one should I format my hard drive as? Is APFS better than Mac OS Extended? Please give me some advice, thanks in advance!

Best Answered by

iBoysoft author Rivers Wong

Rivers Wong

Answered on Thursday, March 9, 2023

Is your external hard drive a solid state drive (SSD) or a hard disk drive (HDD)? If it is an SSD, then APFS is the better choice. But if it is an HDD, I would recommend you format your drive as the Mac OS Extended (Journaled) format.

Let's go back to your question - which one is better, APFS or Mac OS Journaled? The answer is not as simple as a yes or no. Actually, what your friend told you is true, both of these two file systems are very good. The choice should be made on a case-by-case basis.

Mac OS Extended (Journaled) is also known as HFS Plus (HFS +), which is used on all Macs since 1998 (24 years ago) and remained the default Mac OS X file system until APFS replaced it. This file system's "journaled" feature refers to a method of archiving media on the disk. With it, files are less likely to be corrupted when some accidents like sudden power outages happen.

APFS, short for Apple File System, was first introduced with the launch of macOS 10.13 High Sierra in 2017, and replaced Mac OS Extended as the new default file system of Mac hard drives. It is mainly designed for optimizing access to SSDs and flash storage devices.

In terms of file transfer speed, APFS has a higher read and write speed than Mac OS Extended. In terms of compatibility, you can't write to an APFS-formatted drive on a Mac running macOS Sierra and older versions.

But since your Mac is a brand new MacBook Air 2021, its operating system does not have to be taken into account. So here's my recommendation, APFS is better for SSDs and Flash Drive while Mac OS Extended is better for HDDs.

If you still have some problems with this question, you can read this article:

APFS vs. Mac OS Extended - Which Format Option is Better

People Also Ask

Read More Questions

Read More Advice From iBoysoft's Computer Experts

Macintosh HD volume

Macintosh HD vs. Macintosh HD Data: What Are the Differences?

A full explanation about What is Macintosh HD and Macintosh HD - Data. And also tells the difference between Macintosh HD and Macintosh HD - Data.

Wiki Tips

merge apfs container

How To Merge APFS Containers/Partitions to Get More Space

If you have multiple APFS containers or partitions, you can merge the empty/unwanted one to the main container to get a full disk space. This post guides you to merge APFS containers step by step.

How to Tips

Was ist APFS

Apple File System (APFS): Ist es das beste Format für ein Laufwerk

Was ist APFS, einschließlich seiner Betriebssystemkompatibilität, Funktionen und Einschränkungen? Vergleichen Sie außerdem APFS und Mac OS Extended.