Home > Questions

Is APFS better than Mac OS Extended? Which one should I pick for my external SSD?

Hi guys! Recently I want to format my external SSD (used on my M1 MacBook Air 2022) and give it a fresh start. Which file system format should I choose, APFS or Mac OS Extended? Is APFS better than Mac OS Extended or vice versa? To be honest, I know nothing about file systems, can someone give me some advice? Thanks in advance!

Best Answered by

iBoysoft author Rivers Wong

Rivers Wong

Answered on Wednesday, November 23, 2022

If you want to choose a file system for your external SSD, I recommend APFS. But it not means Mac OS Extended is a worse file system compared to APFS, on the contrary, it is a really nice file system.

Actually, no matter whether it is APFS, Mac OS Extended, or FAT and exFAT, they are all common file systems used for Mac computers. Among them, FAT and exFAT are a little bit special cause they are developed by Windows, but are supported by both macOS and Windows.

APFS (the full name is Apple File System) is a proprietary file system developed by Apple. It is the default file system for Mac used in macOS 10.13 and later versions. Since your device is an M1 MacBook Air 2022, you don't have to worry about if the APFS is compatible with your Mac. Also, APFS is designed mainly for solid-state and flash drives.

Mac OS Extended (Journaled) also known as HFS+, HFS Plus, or HFS Extended, is a journaling file system. It is also the primary default file system for Mac drives until APFS replaced it. Differentiated from APFS, Mac OS Extended is a better choice for mechanical drives, or drives used on older macOS since it is a file system used by macOS 10.12 or earlier versions.

There are so many improvements on APFS compared to HFS+, like the huge improvements in metadata, and many actions such as copying and pasting files and folders can be done in an instant on an APFS-formatted drive. But, the biggest advantage of the Apple File System is that it is not compatible with Time Machine backups, which means you can make a copy of your Mac to an APFS drive using Apple's backup tool Time Machine.

But still, APFS is a better choice for your external SDD.

Read more: 

APFS vs. Mac OS Extended - Which Format Option is Better

People Also Ask

Read More Questions

Read More Advice From iBoysoft's Computer Experts

how to encrypt USB on Mac and Windows

How to encrypt, password protect USB drive for Mac & Windows PC usage?

How to encrypt, password protect USB flash drive for Mac and Windows PC usage? With help of M3 Mac BitLocker Loader, BitLocker encrypted USB flash drive can be used for Mac and Windows PC.

Bitlocker Tips

Macintosh HD volume

Macintosh HD vs. Macintosh HD Data: What Are the Differences?

A full explanation about What is Macintosh HD and Macintosh HD - Data. And also tells the difference between Macintosh HD and Macintosh HD - Data.

Wiki Tips

M1 Mac

8 Proved Solutions to External SSD Not Working on M1 Mac

Fix external SSD issues on Apple Silicon M1 Mac if your external hard drive is not working, not mounting, not recognized, or not connecting on M1 Mac.

Mac Data Recovery Tips